Report on Ethiopian Airlines Flight 409 Lebanon crash finds pilot error

Report on Ethiopian Airlines Flight 409 Lebanon crash finds pilot error

Minister of Public Works & Transportation forLebanon, Mr. Ghazi El-Aridi, released the final report of the investigation into the crash of Ethiopian Airlines Flight ET-409, which plunged into the Mediterranean Sea nearlytwo years ago, shortly after taking off fromRafik Hariri International Airport (BEY) inBeirut on Monday, January 25, 2010 at2:41 a.m. local time.

The 191-page document identifies causes of the accident, which took the lives of 82 passengers and 8 crew members, mostlyEthiopian and Lebanese citizens, as well as foreign nationals from 7 other countries, and contains numerous pages of technical data of special interest to commercial pilots and aviation professionals, as reported onTuesday, January 17, 2012 by,Ya LibnanEthiopia ForumsThe Daily StarABC NewsTadius Magazine, and multiple other media sources.

It places responsibility on the flight crew of the Boeing 737-800, registration ET-ANBCaptain Habtamu Benti Negasa and First Officer Alula Tamerrat, saying that the pilot flying the aircraft (PF) had lost situational awareness and failed to follow air traffic control (ATC) instructions; that the monitoring pilot (PM) did not adequately intervene; and that the aircraft went into an uncontrolled spiral dive caused by inconsistent inputs on the aircraft flight controls, flying under great G-force into the sea.

These charges were individually rejected in detailed online documents by Ethiopian Airlines, and theEthiopian Civil Aviation Authority (ECAA), and inAppendix Z of the findings.

An attached slide show with images from the official accident report and video clip also accompany this report.

The French independent agency BEA, Bureau d'Enquêtes et d'Analyses pour la sécurité de l'aviation civile, based at Le Bourget Airport (LBG) near Paris was appointed by both Lebanon and Ethiopia to conduct a scientific analysis and determination into the causes of the accident, assisted by the NTSB and The Boeing Company in the United States, along with representatives from Lebanon and Ethiopia.

According to the agency's official website"The safety investigation, whose sole objective is to prevent future accidents and incidents, includes the gathering and analysis of information, the drawing of conclusions, including the determination of cause(s) and/or contributing factors and, when appropriate, the making of safety recommendations."

BEA continues to define its responsibility by saying that "The identification of causes does not imply the assignment of fault or the determination of administrative, civil or criminal liability."

We have been following this tragic accident for almost two years, and have already published at least 18 factual articles, including detailed photographs, slide shows and video clips from international news agencies.

This dispatch provides an overview of both the official report and the Ethiopian objections, with links to the original source documents, to allow those interested to review them in detail.

The final report was privately circulated to all parties on September 10, 2011, to allow for input, disagreement, and corrections.

It found two basic causes for the accident, shown below in bold type:

1 - The flight crew's mismanagement of the aircraft's speed, altitude, headings and attitude through inconsistent flight control inputs resulting in a loss of control.

2 - The flight crew's failure to abide by Cockpit Resource Management (CRM) principles of mutual support and calling deviations hindered any timely intervention and correction.

It also identified nine contributing factors, also shown below in bold type:

1 - The manipulation of the flight controls by the flight crew in an ineffective manner resulted in the aircraft undesired behavior and increased the level of stress of the pilots.

2 - The aircraft being out of trim for most of the flight directly increased the workload on the pilot and made his control of the aircraft more demanding.

3 - The prevailing weather conditions at night most probably resulted in spatial disorientation to the flight crew and lead to loss of situational awareness.

4 - The relative inexperience of the flight crew on (aircraft) type combined with their unfamiliarity with the airport contributed, most likely, to increase the flight crew workload and stress.

5 - The consecutive flying (188 hours in 51 days) on a new type (of aircraft) with the absolute minimum rest could have likely resulted in a chronic fatigue affecting the captain's performance.

6 - The heavy meal discussed by the crew prior to take-off has affected their quality of sleep prior to that flight.

7 - The aircraft 11 bank angle aural warnings, 2 stalls and final spiral dive contributed in the increase of the crew workload and stress level.

8 - Symptoms similar to those of a subtle incapacitation have been identified and could have resulted from and/or explain most of the causes mentioned above. However, there is no factual evidence to confirm without any doubt such a cause.

9 - The First Officer (F/O) reluctance to intervene did not help in confirming a case of the captain's subtle incapacitation and/or to take over control of the aircraft as stipulated in the operator's Standard Operating Procedure (SOP).

The report also included an extensive series of safety recommendations directed at the Operator, Ethiopian Airlines, the Ethiopian Civil Aviation Authority (ECAA), and the Government of Lebanon, aimed at preventing other accidents from similar causes.

Ethiopian Airlines was told to revise its CRM program (Cockpit Resource Management) and stress First Officer assertiveness and leadership especially in periods of abnormal performance.

It was told to adjust crew pairing and scheduling policies in order to ensure a less stressful cockpit environment, along with other recommendations to assess and detect improved crew performance.

The Ethiopian Civil Aviation Authority was tasked to ensure that the recommendations to the airline have been implemented, and told to re-examine the regulations concerning crew pairing policies.

The International Civil Aviation Organization (IACO) was advised to re-examines international requirements for the identification, training and reporting of subtle incapacitation symptoms and cases.

The accident investigation recommended that the Lebanese Government establishes requirements to ensure that responses to such accidents are made systematically without reliance on foreign assistance.

The Lebanese Director General of Civil Aviation (DGCA) should also re-evaluate the working conditions of the ATC personnel, along with establishing administrative and logistic support for any future investigations.

Ethiopian Airlines (ET) reported a series of exceptions and disagreements with the findings of the report. These can be found in Appendix Z.

In that document, the carrier takes the position that the findings are biased, and heavily influenced by the original position of the Lebanese government which immediately blamed the ET pilots, even before any facts were investigated or evidence recovered.

Such alleged prejudicial reasoning is also called "confirmation bias", meaning that the person or agency holding such a view tends to exclude any evidence which conflicts with its pre-established position, and only focuses on facts and evidence that help to confirm its original position.

The operator has also repeatedly complained that it was excluded from fully participating in the investigation by not being permitted to examine retrieved aircraft parts; to view all of the victim's bodies, of which only a small number were subjected to an autopsy; and pointed out that 92 percent of the aircraft wreckage remained underwater and unrecovered, possibly concealing evidence of a midair fire or explosion.

The airline also objected that investigators ignored critical evidence and eye-witness accounts of an orange ball or fire, which happened before the plane impacted the water.

They point out that the Captain was an experienced pilot with 20 year service and total flying time of 10,233 hours, even though he only had 188 hours as pilot in command (PIC) of a Boeing 737-800, and the First Officer had 350 hours flying this type of aircraft.

Mr. Tewolde Gebremariam, Chief Executive Officer of Ethiopian Airlines, called the report"lacking evidence, incomplete and not presenting the full account of the accident."

He also noted that the report contained "numerous factual inaccuracies, internal contradictions and hypothetical statements that are not supported by evidence," adding that the investigative authority "denied the recovery of the wreckage and ignored crucial information such as security footage, autopsy and toxicology records, baggage screening X-ray records, terminal CCTV records, full Cockpit Voice Recorder (CVR) recovery and read out, allowing victims' bodies to be buried without medical examination and also declining to provide a detailed profile of passengers."

The very fact that Ethiopian Airlines has disputed so many findings, and raised multiple objections, along with the numerous leaks, charges, and counter charges in this incident seems to diminish the credibility of the findings, and more importantly, obscures the truth and raises further controversy.

While we are not in a position to question or criticise the BEA, or the manner in which they exerted their authority in this inquiry, in looking at past investigations in which the NTSB served as the lead agency, it appears in those cases that all potential evidence was investigated, examined, and reviewed in detail without complaints about missing critical facts.

In high profile cases, the independent NTSB has also held frequent conferences with the media, in which members of the public and other concerned parties have been invited to attend. Such events are always open, transparent, video documented, and conducted with full disclosure.

The happenings in Lebanon, by contrast, appear to be heavily influenced by political concerns and national interests, which may have been unavoidable in order for the process to proceed.

We can only hope that such findings are truthful, fair, and accurate, helping to being closure for all of the parties.

Tell us your thoughts. Please leave comments below or by email and subscribe to get future updates. There is also expanded coverage of other recent news articles. You may also wish to follow our dispatches as the News Analysis Examiner.

Tagged as:

Latest news, Ethiopian Airlines Flight 409 Crash, Ethiopian Airlines Flight 409, Lebanon crash, Latest news


162 Views Comments

Tekle-Tsadik Reba, State Minister of Transport Says Increased Traffic Accidents Is A Major Concern

The horrific and non-stopping traffic accident occurring here in the capital and across the nation claiming the lives of innocent citizens has now become a

248 Views Comments

Czech To Begin Its Development Initiatives In Ethiopia

ddis Ababa (HAN) February 27, 2015 – Public Diplomacy and Regional Investment  news.  Ethiopian State Minister Ambassador Berhane meets the Czech Deputy Foreign Minister. State

271 Views Comments

Boeing Sells 'Terrible Teen' B787s To Ethiopian Airlines

Boeing (BOE, Chicago O'Hare) is reportedly in talks with 10 separate buyers concerning the sale of early-model B787-8s, commonly referred to as "Terrible Teens" in


2942 Views Comments

Niseha - Part 2

Watch The Ethiopian Movie "Niseha"

3746 Views Comments

Sebekeya - Part 2

Watch the Ethiopian Movie:  Sebekeya

5407 Views Comments

Adinas - New Ethiopian Movie Trailer

Adinas - New Ethiopian Movie Trailer

18118 Views Comments

Vacation from America

Watch The Ethiopian Movie "Vacation from America?

14667 Views Comments

Newt - Part 2

Watch The Ethiopian Movie "Newt"

8456 Views Comments

Ye Fikir Ken

Watch The Ethiopian Movie "Ye Fikir Ken"


327 Views Comments

WINTA WINTA: The Show - Episode 3

WINTA WINTA: The Show - Episode 3

199 Views Comments

WINTA - WINTA: The Show - Episode 16

WINTA - WINTA: The Show - Episode 16

2689 Views Comments

Artist Helen Berhe Grants An Interview On Sheger Fm

Artist Helen Berhe Grants An Interview On Sheger Fm

200 Views Comments

Fitsum G Tsadik - Sam Argegn (Official Music Video)

 Fitsum G Tsadik - Sam Argegn (Official Music Video)

634 Views Comments

Kibresfaw Habte - Endenema

 Kibresfaw Habte - Endenema

4988 Views Comments

Mengedu - Shewaferahu Desalegn Comedy Drama

Watch Mengedu - Shewaferahu Desalegn Comedy Drama


248 Views Comments

Czech To Begin Its Development Initiatives In Ethiopia

ddis Ababa (HAN) February 27, 2015 – Public Diplomacy and Regional Investment  news.  Ethiopian State Minister Ambassador Berhane meets the Czech Deputy Foreign Minister. State

32 Views Comments

UK Offers Help To Ethiopia's Economic Development

Ethiopia is delivering impressive progress towards the Millennium Development Goals meaning the needs of the country are changing as it experiences strong economic growth and

41 Views Comments

UAE Embassy Attains Suqia Campaign In Ethiopia

The UAE’s Embassy in Ethiopia, in cooperation and coordination with the Emirates Red Crescent, has accomplished the first phase of UAE Suqia Campaign in Ethiopia

30 Views Comments

Redwan: Ethiopia will not be held hostage by Western NGOs Share this post...Minister of the Ethiopian Government Communications Affairs Office, Redwan Hussein, said Ethiopia will not be held hostage by Western NGOs and activists.

375 Views Comments

Turkish Construction Company Builds $1.7 Billion Railway

Yapı Merkezi, a Turkish construction company laid the foundations of the Awash-Kombolcha-Hara Gebeya Railway project in Ethiopia yesterday. The company had won a 391 kilometer-stretch of

37 Views Comments

The Demise Of Karuturistan

It was too good to be true. It is too bad it was true for the people of Gambella in western Ethiopia. Last month, the ignoble